Finlay’s career is long enough that he remembers the days when he used his own hands to actively create photographs in a darkroom. One of the foremost documentary photographers working today, he would be among the first to acknowledge the gifts digital tools have bestowed upon his industry. But watching the girl on a phone editing her dog was quite a sight.
"I thought, so that’s the ubiquitousness of the image. This is what it has been filtered down to and what it has really become. For me, this meant it needed to evolve into a different space. I needed to bring my hands and ideas back to the image," he explains. "There needed to be something that had more of a statement, something that spoke of the individuality that had been reduced and lost."
Finlay spent the ’90s in a darkroom, processing film and making prints. Fast-forward to the digital age, and all he needs his hands for now is hitting a shutter button and picking up prints from the printer. By becoming more hands-on in the process again, he could start exploring other places in his very visual mind.
A month after the Chihuahua incident, Finlay was sitting at his desk staring at a 13×19-inch print of a photograph he had taken of Bobby Kennedy Jr., for Vanity Fair magazine. Knowing there could be more, he began experimenting with oils, acrylics, inks, salt reductions and a combination of other elements until he saw a picture emerging the same way it did in the oversized trays of his darkroom. What Finlay held in his hands now was an original piece of work, more reflective of his spirit and love of a craft that was becoming too mechanically driven for his taste.
"I come from printing all of my own work in a darkroom so I come from a very hands-on background," says Finlay. "The relative ease of digital has also brought a relative sameness to much of the work. What’s happening with digital technology and photography is that what was once a craft has been turned into Guitar Hero for photographers. It’s just really become something that has so aesthetically removed the individual from the actual photograph."
Using the image of Kennedy as a jumping-off point, Finlay has gone on to create a one-off series of stills, often portraits, that tell a multidimensional story of his subject using multiple images in one. Framed by layers of acrylics and oils, in one image the viewer looks through a Gibson guitar to see the musician in the center as he plays it. Closer to the viewer’s eye, the musician stands off to the side with his eyes closed as he listens to playback in the studio. A lyric sheet floats in the background. Another image shows a motorcycle rider from three different perspectives. There’s the portrait of the rider, a portrait of him riding and the detail of the bike. Finlay says the idea began with an oil drip from the rider’s bike. Calling the oil the blood of the motorcycle, he re-creates the look of the oil dropping and splattering to frame the image.